On Tuesday the 27th of October, Opinions Editor, Yue Li, attended the highly anticipated talk in Binks Hall, and now ponders on the stimulating discussions held around the titular question; ‘Who in the World are We?’.
I walked into Leech Hall for the drinks reception with one thing on my mind, and one thing only: photographing the speakers for this article. The room was already alive with conversation. Earlier that evening, in Binks Hall, the Principal had opened ‘Who in the World are We?’ by asking, with a slight laugh, exactly that. The panel sounded like the opening of a joke: a psychiatrist, a theologian and a man who once lived as a badger. Between them, Dr Iain McGilchrist, Dr Eve Poole and Professor Charles Foster moved from mind to machine, from language to nature, and finally to what makes life worth living.
Now snippets of that discussion drifted across the room: what had struck one person most, a question another was still turning over. I joined in, and before I knew it, the last of the daylight had faded.

Only then did I remember the photograph. The speakers had long since left. Not my finest moment as a journalist.
The talk raised more ideas than it had time to explore. One of McGilchrist’s stayed with me: describing the world cannot replace experiencing it. “As soon as you make it explicit,” he said, “you’ve disembodied it.” In his account of the brain’s hemispheres, the left tends to isolate and categorise, while the right attends more broadly to context and the whole.
Foster suggested a further difficulty. Looking at a tree, he found his mind immediately supplying what he already knew about trees: their biology, their classification, fragments of poetry. Before he had properly attended to the tree itself, he was already seeing his ideas about it. His knowledge was not wrong; it had simply got there first.
Yet, as an English student, I am not convinced that knowledge must come at the expense of experience. McGilchrist, who taught English literature at Oxford before becoming a psychiatrist, has applied his argument to poetry. Call Keats’s ‘To Autumn’ a poem about the passing of time and you are right. However, you have said nothing of its heavy ripeness, or of how its final stanza thins into the sounds of evening. Focusing on to what extent Keats achieves these effects can deepen the experience of reading the poem. Perhaps what matters is whether our knowledge takes the place of looking, or gives us reason to look again.
In contrast, Poole found something purposeful in our apparent flaws, such as emotions, mistakes, and uncertainty. What might look like poor design, she suggested, may be precisely how God intended us to learn and relate to one another. Foster also challenged the line we draw between ourselves and other animals. Politics, religion and culture may distinguish us, but he called any fundamental separation “biologically, historically implausible”. This raises a further question, one explored in his wider research: if being distinctive need not mean being separate, need it mean being superior, or might it bring responsibilities towards other creatures?
A few weeks into our first term, we are no longer new here, but not yet settled. The evening’s question has quietly become our own: where do we fit, what makes a life worth living, and how should we live it? Coming when it did, the talk gave us not answers but a place to begin. Those answers, if they come, will come slowly, and from the inside: in what we read, in the place we make our own, in the people we learn to look out for, and, if Poole is right, in the mistakes we will certainly make along the way.
I never did get my photograph. Perhaps I was too busy taking part in what I had come to record.
Image credit: Kathrine Walker.
